The dating site is really easy and convenient to use, but you it will be as legit, the website will start sending you your compatible matches. Top 10 Legitimate Best Dating Sites Free: 1. PlentyOfFish. PlentyOfFish is a free online and best dating site for singles. It is one of the selected. Americans spend millions of dollars each year on paid dating sites. Consumer Reports asks, Do they really get what they pay for?.